Rubric

Find Rubric
Catchment Controls Rubric
Catchment Controls Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Overall Presentation
Does your webpage look aesthetically pleasing, make sense and what you present is logically, helpfully and engagingly laid out?
threshold: pts
15 pts
Full Marks
Exceptional
12 pts
Functional Layout
Everything is logical and correct, though could be more engaging.
9 pts
Confusing or Poor Layout
0 pts
No Marks
pts
15 pts
--
1 - Map of Logan River Watershed
Location Map and Watershed Map (or interactive map where location is clear from zooming out)
threshold: pts
5 pts
Full Marks
Effective, cartographically pleasing and useful map(s).
4 pts
Both Present
Both maps were present, but not cartographically as effective as possible.
3 pts
Missing map
Only had location map or only watershed map.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
5 pts
--
2.1 - Long Profile
A plot of longitudinal profile of Logan River is shown.
threshold: pts
5 pts
Full Marks
Correctly extracted and effectively presented.
4 pts
Correct, but could be more effective.
Cartography and effective presentation and labeling of graphs matter. This is technically correct, but could be more effectively presented.
3 pts
Present but not correct.
Either wrong profile (not of Logan River) or incorrect data or units.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
5 pts
--
2.2 -Base Level Control Today
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
1 pts
Partially correct
Got either elevation or feature wrong (but one right).
0 pts
No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
2.3 -Base Level Control 18,000 BP
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
1 pts
Partially correct
Got either elevation or feature wrong (but one right).
0 pts
No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
2.4 -Mainstem Length of Logan
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
2.5 - Mainstem Concavity
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
1 pts
Partially correct
Either got wrong answer (given inputs you used) or did not show work.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
2.6 - Knickpoints
Label any knickpoints (if present) and pose a working hypothesis about the controls?
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
1 pts
Partially correct
Either incorrectly identified or weak hypothesis.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
3.1 Catchment Length
The catchment length (not the mainstem length).
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing units
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.2 Catchment Area
What is its catchment area in square meters and in square kilometers?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing units
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.3 Catchment Perimeter Length
What is the the catchment perimeter length in meters and kilometers?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing units
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.4 Circularity Ratio
Calculate the circularity ratio.
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or work not shown.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.5 Elongation Ratio
Calculate the elongation ratio.
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or work not shown.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.6 Form Factor
Calculate the form factor of the Logan River Watershed
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or work not shown.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.7 Catchment relief
What is the the catchment relief in meters?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing units
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.8 Relief Ratio
What is the the catchment relief ratio?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing work
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.9 Drainage Density
What is the drainage density of the Logan River perennial drainage network?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing work
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
3.10 Drainage Pattern
What is the drainage pattern of the Logan River perennial drainage network?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value and convincing justification.
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing justification
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
4.1 Stream Order
What is the stream order of the Logan River at its mouth?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing justification
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
4.2 Stream Order Temple Fork
What is the stream order of Temple Fork at its mouth?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing map showing work.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
4.3 Stream Order Beaver Creek
What is the stream order of Beaver Creek at its mouth?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Correct value with units
0.5 pts
Partial Credit
either incorrect value or missing map showing work.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
1 pts
--
4.4 Hortonian laws of stream network composition
Does the Logan River appear to obey the Hortonian laws of stream network composition?
threshold: pts
3 pts
Full Marks
All 3 laws correctly explained.
2 pts
2 of 3 correct
1 pts
1 of 3 correct
0 pts
No Marks
pts
3 pts
--
Methods Described
Methods were adequately described to reproduce results.
threshold: pts
10 pts
Full Marks
8 pts
Missing important elements
Incomplete description or missing key elements to reporduce.
5 pts
Described but...
lacking detail to reporduce and/or incorrect.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
10 pts
--
Total Points: 60 out of 60