Rubric

Find Rubric
Some Rubric
Some Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Overall Presentation
threshold: pts
5 pts
Full Marks
Cartographically impressive. Clear and logical layout with inviting content.
4 pts
Effective
Nothing wrong, but could be more clearly presented.
3 pts
Confusing or Ineffective
0 pts
No Marks
pts
5 pts
--
1. Study Site Description
North Fork Asotin Creek Watershed / Riverscape Description & Maps
threshold: pts
5 pts
Full Marks
Effective map(s) and description
3 pts
Minimal Effort
Ineffective map and/or descriptions.
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
5 pts
--
2.1: In-channel geomorphology of the NF F4 Reach.
Qualitatively describe the in-channel geomorphology of this reach. Use lay person terminology.
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.2: Selection of Survey Years
Choose at least two survey years at this site to consider the temporal variability of morphology at this site. Which survey years are they and why did you choose them?
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.75 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.5 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
1 pts
--
2.3: Tier 2 Forms
What Tier 2 Forms are present in each year? Do they differ between sites?
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.4: Tier 2 Form Assemblage
Do any of the Tier 2 Forms dominate the assemblage or is it fairly mixed? Is this true through time? Answer for both sites.
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.5: Tier 3
What Tier 3 Geomorphic Units are present in each year?
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.6: Arrangement of GUs
Zoom in to 2 to 5 x bankfull width portion of the reach and look at the arrangement of geomorphic units. Is it coherent? Does it make sense based on what you have learned so far?
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.7: Critical Evaluation of GUT Output
How well does GUT appear to be doing in each year at discriminating the in channel geomorphic units? Point out any weaknesses or concerns you might have.
threshold: pts
2 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
1.5 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
2 pts
--
2.7: Manual Mapping
Identify in one of your surveys for this reach a distinctive pool, bar and planar feature. For all three identify all five attributes from the fluvial taxonomy (i.e., Table 6), then use those to identify the tier 3 name from Table 7 or 8 (this may differ than what GUT output is because it is not as resolved) and explain which attribute(s) were key for discriminating that unit from other units.
threshold: pts
3 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
2.25 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
1.5 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
3 pts
--
2.7A1: GU Forcing (Pool)
Identify the GU Forcing Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A2: GU Orientation (Pool)
Identify the GU Orientation Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A3: GU Position (Pool)
Identify the GU Position Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A4: GU Low Flow WS Slope (Pool)
Identify the GU Low Flow WS Slope Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A5: GU Low Flow Relative Roughness (Pool)
Identify the GU Low Flow Relative Roughness Slope Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A6: Tier 3 Name (Pool)
Identify the tier 3 unit name
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A7: Key Attributes (Pool)
Which attributes were key for discriminating?
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7A7: Differences from GUT (Pool)
How different was your mapping and/or categorical identification with GUT
threshold: pts
1 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.76 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.5 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
1 pts
--
2.7B1: GU Forcing (Bar)
Identify the GU Forcing Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7B2: GU Orientation (Bar)
Identify the GU Orientation Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
2.7B3: GU Position (Bar)
Identify the GU Position Attribute
threshold: pts
0.5 pts
Full Marks
Compelling, Correct and Complete
0.38 pts
Partial
2 of 3 (compelling, complete, correct)
0.25 pts
Partial (Less)
1 of 3
0 pts
No Marks
Missing
pts
0.5 pts
--
Total Points: 32 out of 32